Home / Articles / The ATM that asked twice: a Portuguese cash machine offered me a 13.6% mark-up on 200 euros, twice, with a Union Jack beside it, the EU rule that says the mark-up must be shown as a percentage before I confirm, the six levers on two screens, and why an AI agent now lets anyone gather the evidence and challenge it
The ATM that asked twice: a Portuguese cash machine offered me a 13.6% mark-up on 200 euros, twice, with a Union Jack beside it, the EU rule that says the mark-up must be shown as a percentage before I confirm, the six levers on two screens, and why an AI agent now lets anyone gather the evidence and challenge it
By Dinis Cruz · 2026-11-17 · article v1.0.0 · newsroom v0.14.138 · consumersbankingcurrency-conversionregulationportugalevidenceaiarticle
Abstract: This morning I took 200 euros from a cash machine in Portugal with my UK card. The machine offered to charge me in pounds at a "fixed exchange rate guaranteed": 189.68 pounds. I said no, and it asked again on a second screen. I said no again, and my bank charged me 167.12 pounds. The machine's rate was 13.6% above the European Central Bank's reference rate; saying yes would have cost me 22.56 pounds more. This is dynamic currency conversion, and it is legal in the EU, on one condition: since April 2020, Regulation 2019/518 requires the mark-up to be shown as a percentage over the ECB rate before you confirm. Neither screen I photographed shows one. What struck me most was the design: certainty sold against a fear that barely exists, a flag and a familiar total, loaded words, the same question asked twice, a queue behind you, and a bank's name lending trust. And what struck me next is what changed: standing at the machine, nobody can check a rate against the ECB and read a regulation in thirty seconds, but with an AI agent afterwards, in a few minutes, I had the photographs, the rates, the law and the research side by side. That is how a consumer challenges a practice now.
In short
- I took 200 euros from a Portuguese cash machine with a UK card, this morning.
- It offered a "guaranteed" rate of 189.68 pounds, twice. My bank charged 167.12.
- That is a 13.6% mark-up over the ECB rate: 22.56 pounds for nothing.
- It is legal in the EU, if the mark-up is shown as a percentage before you confirm. Neither screen showed one.
- Six levers on two screens do the persuading.
- AI lets a consumer gather the evidence and challenge it, in minutes.
- Always choose the local currency.
Three prices for the same 200 euros
On 17 November 2026 I withdrew 200 euros at a cash machine in Portugal with my UK card. Here are the three prices for the same money:
- The ECB reference rate, the latest available, 16 November: 0.83450 pounds per euro, so 166.90 pounds.
- My bank, which did the conversion when I refused the machine's: 167.12 pounds, within 0.1% of the ECB rate.
- The machine's "guaranteed" rate: 0.94840 pounds per euro, so 189.68 pounds, 13.6% above the ECB rate and 22.56 pounds more than my bank charged.
The whole cost sits in the machine's offer.
What the screens said
The first screen showed the withdrawal, 200,00 EUR, the machine's rate and the total in pounds, and two buttons: "accept without conversion" on the left, and "accept with conversion" on the right, beside a Union Jack.
When I chose the euro, a second screen asked me the same question again: "exchange rate will be determined by your bank" on one side, "fixed exchange rate guaranteed" on the other.
Where the money goes
If you accept, the machine's conversion service turns your euros into pounds at its own rate and keeps the difference, a margin usually shared between the conversion company and whoever hosts the machine. If you decline, the euros go through the card network to your own bank, which converts close to the reference rate. I have not established who runs the conversion on this particular machine, or how the margin is split.
The "guarantee" protects against almost nothing. A cash withdrawal settles within a day or two, and a card issuer's rate normally sits close to the reference rate. A Norwegian bank that looked at 1,500 of its customers' withdrawals abroad found taking the home currency was cheaper in only 4 of them; across Europe, Stiftung Warentest found mark-ups from 2.6% to 12%. This one was above that range.
What the law says
The EU regulated this in Regulation (EU) 2019/518, which added Article 3a to the regulation on cross-border payments. Anyone offering currency conversion at a cash machine or a till must express the total charge as a percentage mark-up over the latest ECB euro reference rate, and show it before the payment starts. That has applied since April 2020, and since April 2021 card issuers must also message their customers with the mark-up after such a payment.
The EU chose transparency, not a ban, even though BEUC, the European consumer organisation, had called this "the great currency conversion scam". On the two screens I photographed, there is a rate and a total, but no percentage mark-up. I did not photograph every screen, so I cannot say none showed it; if none did, the display does not appear to meet Article 3a.
Six levers on two screens
What struck me most was how well designed it is, as persuasion:
- Certainty against fear: "guaranteed" against "determined by your bank" turns a charge into insurance against a risk that barely exists.
- The home-currency anchor: a flag and a total in pounds feel familiar; the euro option shows no total in pounds, so there is nothing to compare.
- Loaded wording: "without conversion" sounds like going without a service.
- Asking twice: a second chance to catch a tired traveller, and the first answer framed as a mistake to correct.
- The setting: a machine in the street, often with a queue behind you; nobody does the arithmetic there.
- Borrowed trust: it is a bank's machine, so "guaranteed" reads as the bank looking after you.
Why I wrote this
Standing at that machine, I could not check the rate against the ECB, read the regulation and work out a percentage in thirty seconds. Nobody can. But afterwards, with an AI agent beside me, it took a few minutes to put the photographs, my bank's record, the reference rate, the law and what consumer groups have found side by side, every claim with its source. My PrompTugal.news newsroom published it first (the original), with the whole evidence pack.
That is the shift I keep coming back to: evidence used to be expensive to gather, so practices like this survived on the fact that challenging them was not worth anyone's time. Now a consumer can gather it, and a regulator can act on it.
What you can do
- Always choose the local currency: "without conversion", or "pay in euros", at cash machines and card terminals.
- Ask for the mark-up: the law says it must be shown as a percentage over the ECB rate before you confirm.
- Complain in Portugal where it is not shown: to the bank, in the Livro de Reclamações (the official complaints book, also online), and to Banco de Portugal through its Portal do Cliente Bancário.
What this does not claim
- One withdrawal, two screens photographed; I cannot say whether an earlier screen showed a percentage.
- I have not established who runs this machine's conversion, or how the margin is split.
- This is not legal advice; whether a display breaches Article 3a is for a regulator.
Where this comes from
My own withdrawal on 17 November 2026: the two screens and my bank's record, photographed that morning; the evidence pack and the original article on PrompTugal.news, written by its conductor agent from my account. The ECB reference rates of 16 November 2026; Regulation (EU) 2019/518 and Regulation (EC) No 924/2009 as amended; BEUC, the great currency conversion scam; the Norwegian study and European mark-ups as reported by Mondaq. The infographics are PrompTugal.news's, CC BY 4.0.
Peer review Not reviewed yet. Review it
Threads
Continued by
- Who wrote it, who steered it, who signs it: the provenance model PrompTugal.news adopted today, a type label, five axes and a ladder from "published by an agent" to "on the record", applied to seven articles on this site, and what the ladder cannot see yet, how much of the author is in a piece, the brief, the corrections and months of background PrompTugal.news's provenance model, a label, five axes and a ladder, applied to seven articles here, and the two measures it misses.
Article No. 452 · start a reading list with it
Reviews
No reviews yet.